Connect With Us

Elite Class Folly in Sonoma County California

By Peter Phillips

The September 29, 2012 opening of the Green Music Center (GMC) at Sonoma State University (SSU) was nothing less than a grand celebration of wealth and privilege. Beaded dresses, tuxedos, and political elites blended in a glorious aristocratic coming out. The ceremonious inauguration was a joining of the regional symphonic upper elites in delusional expectations of continuing high-class cultural immersions.

Built in a time of an economic recession and including $47 million in public bonds, the $150 million GMC represents one of the most opulent expensive building projects in the history of Sonoma County.  The website for the GMC claims it is “Destined to become one of the most sought-after music and arts venues in the world.” “All three floors of Weill Hall are filled with handcrafted, European steamed beech maple seats, which remain acoustically neutral whether occupied or empty.” An A level seat for the first eight concerts costs $626 and B level concerts are $459 for the same. A single ticket for the first concert was $81.00. Dinners at the GMC Prelude restaurant range for $31-50, not including wine.

One attendee was reported to have remarked, “the bathrooms were nicer than my whole house.”

Splendid indeed are the ten majestic 118-year-old olive trees, which grace the Green Music Center’s Trione Courtyard leading to Weill Concert Hall, which are old growth Sevillano olive trees dug up and transported on a flat bed truck from Corning, California.

Weill Hall is named after a semi-billionaire, whose wealth accumulation is directly linked to the impoverishment of millions of American families and home foreclosures in the thousands in Sonoma County.

While SSU is suffering tuition increases, declining student-faculty ratios, and widespread institutional cuts, the corporate media fell over itself with acclaim for SSU President Ruben Armiñana’s “vision”—vaunting magniloquently his personal drive.  Presidents of state colleges, with the approval of the California State University (CSU) trustees, have total financial control over their institutions. Therefore, an administrative manager of a public taxpayer supported university can cozy up to the regional elites and pro-growth forces to build a Taj Mahal without any democratic process with the stakeholders inside the institution or the public at large. This unilateral control is as much about why 73.4% of the SSU faculty in May 2007 voted no confidence in President Armiñana as was the issue of allocation of resources to instruction.

I recently asked my Sociology class of some 45 juniors and seniors if fifteen years ago the SSU development office had said to the students and faculty that they plan to raise $150 million in support of new projects, what would you like to see done with the money—how many would have supported a world-class music hall?  Zero hands went up and laughter filled the room.  Sometimes we can only laugh at the folly of elites.

From a public perspective, $150 million could have had huge regional impacts on poverty, homelessness, home foreclosures, and human misery. The self-aggrandizement of the symphonic elites, many of whom are multi-millionaires and one percenters, manifests a folly so classist as to challenge the very notion of human rights and equal opportunity.

The extravagance of the GMC means  SSU faculty, students, and staff will continue to suffer lost resources long into the future due to continuing expenses in excess of income. All due to the willingness of regional elites and the CSU trustees to support and accept the megalomania vision of a single individual with far too much power.

In a century where humankind faces possible extinction, and 2.5 billion people live on less that $2 a day with some 30,000 dying everyday from malnourishment and simply cured diseases, wealth concentration is sinful and the celebration of wealth with grandiose monuments is the mortal sin of the elite.

Someday, these monuments to wealth will be occupied, renamed and  democratically modified to meet the needs of the people. In the meantime, we must continue to denounce  classism and mobilize collectively for global human betterment.  weill hall ds 10 630x310 150x150 Elite Class Folly in Sonoma County California________________________________________________________________________

Peter Phillips is a professor of Sociology at Sonoma State University and President of Media Freedom Foundation.

 

 

  • Northbay Communitarian October 18, 2012

    bravo! this is an insightful article describing the absolute waste of money forced upon the community by these selfish individuals. “Their” culture is wasted on exclusivity for only a few thousand individuals… why not use the money for 10 cultural venues for the people? In a broad sense, this article serves to point out what’s wrong with the values governing our system, and the great divide between these individuals and the majority of the people these individuals lord over…

  • Northbay Communitarian October 18, 2012

    bravo! this is an insightful article describing the absolute waste of money forced upon the community by these selfish individuals. “Their” culture is wasted on exclusivity for only a few thousand individuals… why not use the money for 10 cultural venues for the people? In a broad sense, this article serves to point out what’s wrong with the values governing our system, and the great divide between these individuals and the majority of the people these individuals lord over…

  • M. NAAAM, E. October 21, 2012

    Thank you very much for this article; I have searched endlessly for “substantial” evidence of the growing elite of Sonoma County (I have seen such with mine own eyes, is that not enough?), and this article is a perfect article for my quest to spread the word about the opulence manifesting in and corrupting my home.

  • M. NAAAM, E. October 21, 2012

    Thank you very much for this article; I have searched endlessly for “substantial” evidence of the growing elite of Sonoma County (I have seen such with mine own eyes, is that not enough?), and this article is a perfect article for my quest to spread the word about the opulence manifesting in and corrupting my home.

  • Geoff H October 21, 2012

    Similar nonsense here at College of the Desert (Palm Springs) where the voters were sold on a bond issue of about $300M (now closer to $1B) to accommodate growth by building lots and lots of buildings. Now the public sees fewer and fewer sections available at the same time that these new buildings are built. They wonder, no doubt, why the bond money can’t be used where it’s needed: to provide classes for students?

  • Geoff H October 21, 2012

    Similar nonsense here at College of the Desert (Palm Springs) where the voters were sold on a bond issue of about $300M (now closer to $1B) to accommodate growth by building lots and lots of buildings. Now the public sees fewer and fewer sections available at the same time that these new buildings are built. They wonder, no doubt, why the bond money can’t be used where it’s needed: to provide classes for students?

  • Rick Deal October 28, 2012

    I agree with you on this one. The money could have been better used for tuition and educational departments or upgrading the buildings instead of this massive construction. This is going on all over California and other universities nationwide. More and more is going into online education (another money making scheme) instead of quality in class education to prepare for jobs in the modern economy.

  • Rick Deal October 28, 2012

    I agree with you on this one. The money could have been better used for tuition and educational departments or upgrading the buildings instead of this massive construction. This is going on all over California and other universities nationwide. More and more is going into online education (another money making scheme) instead of quality in class education to prepare for jobs in the modern economy.

  • Roger January 10, 2013

    Yes,but….have you attended a concert in the new hall? I’m a retired schoolteacher who shares much of your basic perspective. I too am ashamed that someone like Sandy Weil has his name on the hall. I was proud when some of the faculty and students stood up and turned their backs on Weil when we received an “honorary” Phd. from Sonoma State. But the music! We’ve been subscribers to the Santa Rosa symphony for 20 years, including the last 10 years when we have had to drive up from the immediate Bay Area to attend concerts. We are immensely proud of the orchestra and the heroic efforts of Corrick Brown and Jeff Kahane to help raise the money to build the hall. Admittedly, Arminanas plan must include a gamble that the hall will become self supporting. At least forus we hope he makes it. A lot of people will have great joy during the performances if he does.
    Roger sailorrog@earthlink.net

  • Roger January 10, 2013

    Yes,but….have you attended a concert in the new hall? I’m a retired schoolteacher who shares much of your basic perspective. I too am ashamed that someone like Sandy Weil has his name on the hall. I was proud when some of the faculty and students stood up and turned their backs on Weil when we received an “honorary” Phd. from Sonoma State. But the music! We’ve been subscribers to the Santa Rosa symphony for 20 years, including the last 10 years when we have had to drive up from the immediate Bay Area to attend concerts. We are immensely proud of the orchestra and the heroic efforts of Corrick Brown and Jeff Kahane to help raise the money to build the hall. Admittedly, Arminanas plan must include a gamble that the hall will become self supporting. At least forus we hope he makes it. A lot of people will have great joy during the performances if he does.
    Roger sailorrog@earthlink.net